マンモス漁師の身長は178㎝
University debate: “Height is in the genes. Meat and milk have nothing to do with it.”
Geneticist: “Height is about 80% heritable. Tall parents have tall children. The Dutch are tall because they’re Dutch and the Maya are short because they’re Maya. You cannot drink your way to six foot.”
Anthropologist: “The Maya of Guatemala are among the shortest people on earth. Agreed?”
Geneticist: “The textbook example of a genetically short population.”
Anthropologist: “In the 1980s thousands of Maya families fled to Florida and California. Their children were measured. Inside one generation they stood four inches taller than Maya children of the same age back home.”
Geneticist: “Clean water. Healthcare.”
Anthropologist: “And a fridge. Take the 105 countries with decent records and ask what best predicts how tall the men are. The answer is how much of their protein comes from milk, meat, eggs and fish. The more of it comes from wheat and rice, the shorter they get.”
Geneticist: “That’s a correlation.”
Anthropologist: “It’s a correlation that follows the herds. The tallest people in Europe live in the mountains of Bosnia and Montenegro, on sheep, cheese and milk. The tallest in Africa are the Dinka, who live off their cattle and average close to six foot. And the mammoth hunters of Ice Age Europe stood about five foot ten.”
Geneticist: “Cavemen were five foot ten?”
Anthropologist: “Then their descendants took up farming and lost four or five inches. Europe didn’t get them back until the twentieth century, when the meat and the milk came back.”
Geneticist: “So genes do nothing at all.”
Anthropologist: “Genes set the ceiling. Dinner decides how much of the room you get. Nobody’s DNA changed on the flight to Florida.”
Geneticist: “I’m five foot six and I was perfectly well fed.”
Anthropologist: “On what?”
Geneticist: “Cereal, mostly. Toast. Orange squash.”
Anthropologist: “Then I’m sorry. You’d be making this argument from further up.”
— Sama Hoole (@SamaHoole) November 17, 2026